My oncologist said as younger women have such resistant ovaries in his experience Tamoxifen often doesn't work effectively in women in my age group (which I assume would be the 35 and under age group? The group who it is designed for...)
He explained as we (women under 35) have so many hormones pulsing about and our ovaries are in full on baby production mode... trying to suppress the hormones is very difficult and he said he felt Tamoxifen didn't work for around 50% of women in my age group due to either the hormone thing or the CYP2D6 problem....
After 4 months on Tamoxifen I had estrogen levels of 1800 and was still ovulating & menstrating...that being said however,.. I have very high levels of Estrogen naturally, higher than most women and he told me from the start he felt I would be very hard to suppres my hormones with drugs and that he thought I was best to go for the surgery...He was also surprised that even the Zoladex took 4 months and I am still ovulating! That's why he thinks that even the Zoladex may not even suppress everything effectively....
All that being said...other women have said to me that they have still had periods, and no other menopausal symptoms on Tamoxifen and there oncologists haven't been worried that it isn't working so I asked my Gp "how do you know if the Tamoxifen is wotking or not" he didn't know....and my oncologist said that you shouldn't be menstrating on it...so I don't know really...knowing how Tamoxifen works (blocks the estrogen receptors in the breast tissue) I am wondering if you can still be menstraing and the Tamoxifen is still working? The radiation oncologist even said that even if I had high levels of estrogen in my blood it didn't mean that the Tamoxifen wasn't working... so who knows! if the experts can't agreee on it, what hope do the rest of us have! I guess it comes down to how much you trust your oncologist and their knowledge of what they are doing......there are plenty of people out there who aren't good at their jobs...Doctors included...