HI Debbie - I was diagnosed with DCIS in March last year. Had lumpectomy in April 2010 however with horrid family history chose to have a bilateral mastectomy in July 10. I was lucky that my cancer at the time was not invasive, so i had the "luxury" of being able to make all my decisions with time on my side (although really how much time is ever enough?).
With the inisidious disease that we are dealing with, unfortunately many women do not have the "luxury" that I had, and time is of the essence. So we make decisions at a point in time which are right for us at that time. If we had either a crystal ball or hindsight to be able to make those decisions with, then our choices would all be "easy and right" (?!).
From a peace of mind perspective I don't regret my mastectomy decision for one moment as I always viewed my boobs as ticking timebombs so to be rid of them is such a weight off my shoulders.
BUT no matter what I had thought of them for the last 47 years, I have days that I miss them and think that it would be nice to have a chest that was not numb, instead of boobs that I can't feel being touched. I continually look at and feel my reconstructed boobs and wonder if I ever will really get used to them. BUT I still do not want my old ones back!
I am sure that everyone one of us have days that we "wish" for something different but we learn to live with who we are and what we have (or haven't!) got!
I have many friends that have had lumpectomys and the cancer has never returned.
However, I personally know what it's like to have a cloud hanging over your head that you just can't see past, so if peace of mind is what you need, no matter what anyone else thinks, then discuss your options with your specialist.
Keep sharing your thoughts in this forum, cause there are many ears here to listen and share with you!!
Bye Leanne :-)