Forum Discussion

Lallaby's avatar
Lallaby
Member
8 years ago

Choosing Implant or Prosthesis

Hi Everyone
I was diagnosed with BC in November and have just finished 8 Dose Dense Chemo Treatments. I got though that OK without any real serious side effects but the tumour didn't shrink as much as expected. A nipple sparing mastectomy is scheduled for after Easter.
My Dilemma is what to do after the mastectomy.  I may be able to have immediate reconstruction with an implant, depending on what is found during the operation, (radiation still may be needed) but I am not sure I want to go through the hassle of having an implant, possible follow up surgery and associated risks of implants. Is there anyone who wishes to share their experience with an implant and also anyone who can share their experience with a breast prosthesis. Choosing no reconstruction sounds like the easiest option with the quickest recover and no additional risks but I don't know how practical (or annoying :) ) a prosthesis is. I am only a 14B bra size . Looking forward to some feedback. Thanks!

15 Replies

  • Hi @Lallaby, I had a skin and nipple sparing mastectomy and went straight to implant. I also had a sentinel node biopsy and my surgeon used the same incision to do that too!! I was in hospital for 6 days and left with two drains hanging out my side. First removed 5 days after leaving hospital and the second 8 weeks later!! Only reason it was in so long was because the fluid levels wouldn't drop - turns out it was the drain itself causing irritation. Would I do it again - you betcha!!!!! I am incredibly happy with my implant. It is a D cup - I had been a C cup prior but my surgeon sheepishly told me on the day of surgery that she'd mismeasured me and I was going up a size. No drama's there. I have posted photos in the choosing reconstruction site. If you have any questions that I can help you with please don't hesitate to ask. All the best with your decision. Xx Cath
  • Hi 
    I have a prosthesis. I was never very keen on reconstruction and I had a persistent seroma that took 12 months and surgery to fix, which made me feel hesitant about further surgery. I am quite large breasted so going without anything would be very noticeable. I find a prosthesis easy. Unlike @primek, I am only an occasional, holiday swimmer and I just use a synthetic pad in my swimsuit. The prosthesis lasts about 2 years, and I get it fully rebated every 2 years.  A properly fitted prosthesis has the right weight and shape. Some women living in the north report that they find them hot- I live in Melbourne and have no difficulty even in hot weather (we do have that too!). I also don't have a problem with how I look - I have a large scar and it's a bit 'untidy' - my surgeon left enough to assist a reconstruction if I wanted one and that also gives me a bit of cleavage, which is good!  It's me, I am fine with the way it is, it doesn't concern my partner either and after I had stripped off in a shared shower in Iceland before getting in a hot tub, I don't think I'd think twice about doing that again! No-one batted an eyelid. It's a really personal thing - to reconstruct or not - and it's what's right for the individual that matters. Best wishes,
  • You are ideal for a breast implant if you want reconstruction. If you join the  reconstruction group you can discuss the various different options. Being a B cup you could go possibly go directly to implant with a dermal sling. So one surgery. Changeover surgery (10 plus years) is very short. I had tissue expanders in first and 3/4 filled until after chemo. One fill then changeover after. I stayed  in hospital 48 hours for protective antibiotics. I only required panadol for pain management once returned to ward. The initial surgery is painful, but everyone copes differently. All surgery has infection risks whether straight mastectomy or reconstruction. 

    I personally didn't want the hassle of a prosthesis (or 2 in my case) I like to swim. So yes...a bit of hassle with surgery but once healed up you are pretty right for many years. With a posthesis you may need new ones every couple of years.  You need special bras and special swimsuits etc and it can be expensive.
    Many women do this and are perfectly happy. 

    The breast reconstruction group also has photo stories to give you an idea of possible cosmetic outcome. I would have loved to have saved my nipples but it wasn't possible. 

    @socoda went directly to implant with  great results.