Forum Discussion

hdubs's avatar
hdubs
Member
15 years ago

Saline or Silicone?

I'm going to have to make a decision in a couple of months when my reconstruction is due to be finished and my tissue expander gets swapped out for a breast implant. Do I go saline or silicone?  I've done some reading and it seems it's six of one, half a dozen of the other.  The risks and benefits are pretty much the same so I'm tending towards saline because I think if the silly thing ruptures, I'd rather have saline leaking in my body than silicone.  The tissue expander is just a bag with saline in it after all and it looks OK.

It would be great to hear from someone who's faced the same sort of decision.

21 Replies

  • Thanks Di.  Greatly appreciated. Have had a pretty horrible week so it was nice to have someone say something nice.

     

    Take care.

    Tracey xx

     

  • Hey Tracey -- sorry for butting in on your conversation, but I saw your comment and wanted to wish you all the best for Monday.  Hope it all goes well!  :)

    ~Di

  • Hi Helen,

    I am now going in on Monday.  Going to have saline.  Will let you know how it goes.

    Take care.

    Tracey x

  • Hi everyone

    I saw my surgeon a couple of weeks ago and asked him for a saline implant.  I was ready to make my case to him if he was going to recommend a silicone one.  But he basically just said OK and that it's been three years since he last put in a saline one.

    I'm having the op at the end of the month and will report back Tracey once it's all settled down.

    Helen.

  • Nice Profile Pic there.  I'm a little bit of a fan too.

    I am about to change over from my tissue expander and I am having the same thoughts.  I'm not sure which way I will go.  Part of me wasn't going to go with a reconstruction, but I am big busted (even though I had a reduction when I had the xpander put in) and I was having a lot of pain in my neck, back and shoulder.  When I went to a different surgeon (first one told me it was a waste of time with me being advanced) he told me it needed to be done as I shouldn't have to go through other pain along with anything else I might have to go through.

    I am still unsure which way to go.  I think I prefer the thought of saline, as after all I am really only after the bump and some weight so that the other pains go.

    Good luck with your choice.

    Tracey xx

  • Nice Profile Pic there.  I'm a little bit of a fan too.

    I am about to change over from my tissue expander and I am having the same thoughts.  I'm not sure which way I will go.  Part of me wasn't going to go with a reconstruction, but I am big busted (even though I had a reduction when I had the xpander put in) and I was having a lot of pain in my neck, back and shoulder.  When I went to a different surgeon (first one told me it was a waste of time with me being advanced) he told me it needed to be done as I shouldn't have to go through other pain along with anything else I might have to go through.

    I am still unsure which way to go.  I think I prefer the thought of saline, as after all I am really only after the bump and some weight so that the other pains go.

    Good luck with your choice.

    Tracey xx

  • I don't have any implant advice, I just wanted to admire your Starfleet Command user pic!  :)

  • I had a latissimus dorsi reconstruction so the tissue expander is sitting between the chest and the back muscles.  I had it done in January and it hasn't needed to be topped up since then so I'm not really sure how much saline is actually in it.  It doesn't have as much "give" as my natural breast, but almost does.  It's soft and comfortable to sleep on, etc, but if I poke around deep enough I can feel the resistance of it.  All up, it's not real but it's close enough for me.