I think I would be going back to tell him my opinion, but I doubt I would ask him for a redo. I got an excellent reconstruction done by a plastic surgeon. It is still painful at times even though there is no feeling. I did baulk at getting a new nipple and now proudly wear a fake one!! Even my plastic surgeon said to me on a follow up visit : "I didn't do that nipple did I?" When I told him it was fake he wanted to take photos to show other patients. Sorry you have this on top of the "tit trip".