Forum Discussion

hdubs's avatar
hdubs
Member
14 years ago

Mammogram/Ultrasound/MRI or all of the above

A milestone last Friday.  Visited my surgeon and had the last of my stitches out.  Now I only need to see him every year for a mammogram on my remaining breast.  Since that breast is as lumpy as a bag of potatoes, having just a mammogram is not going to give me peace of mind.  I've had mammograms since I was 40 and none of them picked up my DCIS or my two breast cancers.  In fact, I hardly know anyone whose cancer was picked up by a mammogram. 

I'd like to ask him to put me in for an ultrasound and maybe also an MRI to back up the mammogram. 

Does anyone have more than just a mammogram at their annual visits?

20 Replies

  • Thank you everyone.  I'm determined now to have an ultrasound but not looking forward to trying to persuade my surgeon to let me have one. I think he might have me pigeonholed as a worrier and try to talk me out of it. Still he might surprise me.

    Helen xx

  • Thank you everyone.  I'm determined now to have an ultrasound but not looking forward to trying to persuade my surgeon to let me have one. I think he might have me pigeonholed as a worrier and try to talk me out of it. Still he might surprise me.

    Helen xx

  • My 2 yearly mammogram detected my IDC in July 2011. Even with ultrasound precision I still could not feel the lump (14mm) just under the skin. I had skin puckering but I hadn't noticed that at all.

     

    I intend to have both mammogram and ultrasound each year from now on.

     

    I am now 6 weeks post radiation treatment. The skin looks a fairly good colour, wounds healed up well. With a full axillary clearance the fluid isn't draining and I have 'congestion' in the breast. I need to make sure it doesn't turn in to lymphodema. I have to massage my breast twice a day - weird! :)

    Jenny

  • Hi,  I was diagnosed just over 3 years ago.  I could see the lump at the top of my left breast but the mammo didn't show it.  The ultrasound did.  I have a yearly check with both.  I would never trust a mammo only.

    Best of luck,    Jill xx

  • It is interesting to read that most of the women commenting on this page have not had good luck with mammograms as a method of BC detection. I have bigger breasts and because of this very fact, my BC was undetectable by feel, even the surgeon could not feel it, 2.5 cm lump, after it had been detected by my 2 yearly mammogram. Because I had no family history of BC, I had no idea that I had it, so 2 yearly checks were all I did. But I am glad you are all saying it as it is, because I am about to make the appt for the 1 yr mammo, and think I might ask for the ultrasound too.

  • Hi

    I understand your misgivings about Mammogram as I found my lump 4.9cms! about 4 months after an all clear one! Last year I had a mammogam and ultrasound of my remaining breast and already have the form from my surgeon for this year. I also had lumpy breasts but seems to have become softer since chemo and tamoxifen when the girl did the ultrasond she commented on the change in my breasts it freaked me to start but realised she was comparing it to my previous ultrasound when I had BC diagnosed.

    Definitely have ulttrasound it is very accurate on breasts and less radiation than MRI. Good luck

    Sarah x

  • Hi

    I understand your misgivings about Mammogram as I found my lump 4.9cms! about 4 months after an all clear one! Last year I had a mammogam and ultrasound of my remaining breast and already have the form from my surgeon for this year. I also had lumpy breasts but seems to have become softer since chemo and tamoxifen when the girl did the ultrasond she commented on the change in my breasts it freaked me to start but realised she was comparing it to my previous ultrasound when I had BC diagnosed.

    Definitely have ulttrasound it is very accurate on breasts and less radiation than MRI. Good luck

    Sarah x

  • I've always had mammograms and ultrasounds together since my first cancer when I was 34. I found the first one myself. I also found my second cancer myself when I was 43, just 4 months after a clear mammogram and ultrasound. Luckily, both of my tumours were easy to feel, with the second one being very close to the surface. I don't want to keep getting my remaining breast squished and ultrasounded each year, so I'm planning on having it removed. I don't think I can fully trust the screening any more, and I really don't want to have chemotherapy a third time!! xx Jane
  • I've always had mammograms and ultrasounds together since my first cancer when I was 34. I found the first one myself. I also found my second cancer myself when I was 43, just 4 months after a clear mammogram and ultrasound. Luckily, both of my tumours were easy to feel, with the second one being very close to the surface. I don't want to keep getting my remaining breast squished and ultrasounded each year, so I'm planning on having it removed. I don't think I can fully trust the screening any more, and I really don't want to have chemotherapy a third time!! xx Jane
  • I always have a mammo and ultrasound.  I too agree with the mammo not being so reliable. My first bc was picked up by "moi" and the second on an ultrasound.  I like to have a full body scan at least yearly.  It is 5 years since the first diagnosis and 1 year since the 2nd.  I hate having both tests as my breasts are still very tender.  If you want a test carried out - then ASK for it.  It is your body and health.  I am much more "upfront" these days and we all should be. XLeonie