Forum Discussion
Oncotype Testing
I was diagnosed with Early Cancer - Oestrogen Positive - 3 February 2022. Since then I have had surgery to remove the lump.
I saw my oncologist this week for a treatment plan. Due to my history, Hodgkins lymphoma 1998 and non Hodgkins lymphoma 2008 , sister and other family members with Breast Cancer, and the markers found in my lump she wasn't sure if Chemo would be a beneficial option. She has suggested Oncotype Testing to give a 100% guarantee that Chemo is needed or not. I have no worries with this as I'd rather not have chemo if it is not needed. What go me mad was the cost of this test $5000!!!! There is no Medicare rebate and not covered by my Health Fund, I was fortunate that we were able to juggle a few things around to pay for this - but what about those who can't afford this. When the information provided isn't that clear and it's a matter of a coin toss whether to have or not have chemo what would you do? I know it makes it sound like my oncologist isn't giving me clear advice but she is very and good and has provided me with lots of information, hence taking the option to do this testing.
Cancer is hard enough as it is without the added financial strain of such an expensive test. There are so many other subsidised tests and programs why isn't this one. Apparently we are the only Western Nation where the government doesn't provide a rebate.
I have wrote to the Minister for Health a strongly worded letter and suggest that everyone do the same.
I saw my oncologist this week for a treatment plan. Due to my history, Hodgkins lymphoma 1998 and non Hodgkins lymphoma 2008 , sister and other family members with Breast Cancer, and the markers found in my lump she wasn't sure if Chemo would be a beneficial option. She has suggested Oncotype Testing to give a 100% guarantee that Chemo is needed or not. I have no worries with this as I'd rather not have chemo if it is not needed. What go me mad was the cost of this test $5000!!!! There is no Medicare rebate and not covered by my Health Fund, I was fortunate that we were able to juggle a few things around to pay for this - but what about those who can't afford this. When the information provided isn't that clear and it's a matter of a coin toss whether to have or not have chemo what would you do? I know it makes it sound like my oncologist isn't giving me clear advice but she is very and good and has provided me with lots of information, hence taking the option to do this testing.
Cancer is hard enough as it is without the added financial strain of such an expensive test. There are so many other subsidised tests and programs why isn't this one. Apparently we are the only Western Nation where the government doesn't provide a rebate.
I have wrote to the Minister for Health a strongly worded letter and suggest that everyone do the same.
20 Replies
- My niece just came back from Texas after being there for 8 years. She is so happy to be back in Australia where she knows she is guaranteed health care. It was a very expensive event for her to have her baby and a general trip to emergency could cost upwards of $3000. When she came here and had to take her baby to the hospital she was surprised to be able to walk away without having to answer a million questions and how will payment me made before having her baby looked at.
I know our medical system isn't the best and can be frustrating but at least we aren't turned away when we do require medical help. I am fortunate to be able to afford health cover so I can be treated when I need to, but I know if I wasn't covered that in an emergency I would be treated no questions asked.
We will never have an answer for all our medical problems but I ham grateful for what we do have. I will continue to lobby our government for better support and who knows it might help. - try and. See a documentary Michael Moore made on usa health system called sicko —-frightening. Did you know the health funds in usa can refuse to fund treatment , that here in Australia our drs would want us to have ? They spoke to a nurse who’s husbands bone marrow,transplant treatment was refused by the health fund , and then he died as he refused to,sell his house to fund it himself as he didn’t want to leave his family in a dire position if he didn’t make it .If he’d been in Australia he would have received that transplant .
That’s tip of the iceberg .
our system , whilst not perfect , certainly doesn’t have those inequities
if you’re insured a health fund cannot refuse you treatment , nor can they kick you out if they think you’re costing them too much
if not insured ok we may have wait lists but it works well in most circumstances - Hi there
I know there are many competing matters for government funding including health funding and it is only going to get worse with an ageing population.
That is why an organisation such as BCNA is important to advocate for us on issues such as this.
I do take issue with the statement that the American health system is superior to ours.
It seems from my observations that is you have money there you get a good experience but if you don’t it’s generally a much inferior experience to here.
No system is perfect. - Agree @Lisa1407, my American penfriend (of 50+ years) has the supposedly top cover through her husband's employment but even that is really lacking for her.
We are indeed fortunate here, even though if we don't have private insurance we may need to wait a bit more time for treatment for things such as hip and knee replacements. If we need heart etc due to urgency we are in and treated byt the best possible (though some may be in a teaching hospital and be treated by a student). - @Lisa1407 would be good if we get new money put into health, especially for the aged who without private cover wait a long time for knee replacements and hip replacements. If more people that could afford private cover took it up it would put less strain on the public health system here. Two tier systems can work well if people didn't want everything for nothing. I hope we are not disappointed and keep on striving to have the best health care system in the world, agree with much you have stated Lisa. xx
- Although our health service here in Australia could do with a lot more government funding to get us access to all of the drugs and tests that are available in the US, it is worth remember that not every American has such access! It is only those Americans who can afford health insurance that get this access (and even some insurance don't provide access to everything). I would much rather be looked after in a health system that at least tries hard to achieve equity of access. I am looking forward to seeing if there is any new money put aside for health in the election promises (I think I will be disappointed though)!
- @SylviaM I am very grateful also, but good we don't get complacent and brag how great our system is, it clearly isn't great for all Australians. So pleased you are proactive and wrote to the Health Minister, because many wouldn't do that if it isn't of personal concern to them. You have a big heart :) xx
- @Keeping_positive1 As to date I have heard nothing from the Health Minister & doubt I will.
Our health system does have a long way to go but I am so grateful for what we do have. Finding the money for the oncotype wasn't easy and I can imagine that many people would be in the same boat. The fact that there are so many illnesses for which research is so far behind is frustrating.
We can only hope that with all the promises being made by politicians they might find it within themselves to dedicate more money to funding and improving the health care system. - It pees me off no end when I hear some people sprout we have the best free health system in the world. We clearly do not! We are 10 years behind the USA with the latest breast cancer treatments for example. We also waited a very long time to have the 3D mammograms available to women as a first screening point!
It was clear for me that I needed chemo as was in the lymph nodes, but if I had to make a decision myself I would not have been able at the time to pay for an oncotype test, and I would have taken the chemo, and perhaps unnecessarily cause immuno compromised issues! There are other women and men who also would be in a similar boat to me. I know money doesn't buy health, but it can sure help with getting the best treatment, or avoiding unnecessary treatment. Very grateful I was able to get the treatment I required, but still have compassion for those that simply cannot have this oncotype test because of financial barriers at the time.
I agree we should all write to the Health Minister and local member! - Yippee, so pleased to hear your good news. :)
